FNC Follows Up on Journalists’ Group Push to Change ‘Illegal’ to ‘Undocumented’

January 4, 2011

By Matt Philbin
Culture and Media Institute
January 3, 2011

On Dec. 14, 2010, the Culture and Media Institute reported that the Society for Professional Journalists (SPJ)’s Diversity Committee announced a year-long campaign to “educate journalists about the hurtfulness of phrases like ‘illegal immigrant,’ which is the term currently preferred by the influential AP Stylebook.”

After the Daily Caller picked up the story, the Fox News Channel followed suit. On Jan. 3, “Fox & Friends’” host Steve Doocy interviewed Leo Laurence, a member of SPJ’s Diversity Committee, who couched the society’s advocacy as a constitutional issue.

“The problem,” Laurence said, “is that under our Constitution, everyone, including non-citizens, are presumed to be innocent of any crime until proven guilty in the court of law. Therefore, only a judge can say when someone is illegal. So we’re urging journalists to use the phrase, undocumented immigrant, not illegal immigrant.”

Furthermore, Laurence asserted that, “It’s a very conservative issue because we’re following our constitution.”

Since the Constitution doesn’t require torturing language to score a political point, Doocy was rightly skeptical. “So you’re saying until the [illegal immigrant] has been through the system, adjudicated, you simply cannot say that?”

“That’s correct,” answered Laurence, and smugly gave out his personal phone number and e-mail on the air for “anybody [that] wonders about that.”

As CMI pointed out last month, in advocating for language that contorts and obscures the illegal status of the immigrants in question, the Society for Professional Journalists is abandoning journalism and taking a side in a political issue. It is also insulting American media consumers’ intelligence. A drunk driver is a drunk driver, even if he hasn’t been caught by the police and declared guilty by a judge.

It seems the SPJ itself realizes, if belatedly, the absurdity of Laurence’s assertion. His original article now sports the following note right at the top:

CLARIFICATION: The following article is an opinion piece and does not reflect the views of SPJ, its membership or its Diversity Committee. The committee itself has taken no official initiative on the use of the phrase “illegal immigrant.”


One Response to “FNC Follows Up on Journalists’ Group Push to Change ‘Illegal’ to ‘Undocumented’”

  1. Oscar Castaneda on January 5th, 2011 1:07 am

    Hello Matt, please know before hand that I’m a US citizen, but because I’m as hispanic looking as anyone born of latinamerican parents, I’m more often than not assumed “illegal” and yes before a fellow citizen brands me “illegal” I’d like my constitutional right to be assumed “inocent”. You ought to be ashamed.
    Oscar Castaneda.

Got something to say?

Home | About | Archives | Advertising | Contact | Privacy Policy

MetroCatholic, Inc · 5604 Belton Ln. · Suite 400 · McKinney, TX 75070
Ph. (972) 400-2423 · Fax (888) 248-7696

The sites and respective links above offer additional information on the Catholic faith. Please note that DFW Catholic is not officially associated with any of these sites and is unable to effectively monitor all information contained therein. Please use your own judgement when visiting these or any websites. If you find information that is objectionable, contact us.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivatives License. You may republish an article without request provided the content is not altered and it is clearly attributed to "MetroCatholic". Any Internet re-publishing of original MetroCatholic articles MUST additionally include a live link to http://www.dfwcatholic.org. Republishing of articles on DFWCatholic.org that have come from other news sources as noted is subject to the conditions of those sources. MetroCatholic may at times publish content that is taken from the internet and thus considered to be in the public domain. Anyone contrary to the publication of said content need only to contact the editorial office which will immediately proceed to remove the content.