Luke 9:7-9 Perplexed

Luke 9:7-9  Perplexed
Herod the tetrarch heard about all that was happening, and he was greatly perplexed because some were saying, “John has been raised from the dead”; others were saying, “Elijah has appeared”; still others, “One of the ancient prophets has arisen.”  But Herod said, “John I beheaded.  Who then is this about whom I hear such things?”
Herod looked perplexed.  He couldn’t believe what he was hearing.  Things were not as self-evident as he thought they were.  After all, he had killed The Baptist.  That should have been the end of the story.  Never did he ever imagine that it was the beginning of the story.
Not too long ago, I gave a talk at a Catholic school.  To my “Catholic” audience, I told them that if they wished to ever be a better Christian, then they must learn to think logically and live “illogically”.  Of course my young audience was a little perplexed, but I went on to explain how they must constantly be searching for the truth, in a very logical and structured way, but continue to live like Christ, who spoke and lived in a very “illogical” or “paradoxical” way. 
I then went on to explain to them the failures of atheism.  How atheism is nothing more than a backhanded slap on the face of God and more of a frontal attack on wonder and faith.  For the atheist, nothing is surprising, not even evil; nothing is beautiful, not even love; nothing is exciting, not even life.  It is all what it was supposed to be.  It is as thrilling and as amazing as dissecting a worm.    
For them, everything is self-evident…except for The Everything!  They say, “Of course the Universe exists, duh?!  What did you expect?”  Or, “Of course an apple falls from a tree.  It’s all based on the laws of physics!” …It’s as if the laws of atoms were like the laws of governments…not made but self-evident.
An atheist prides himself on believing only what he can see, and not what others have seen, which to him means everyone is sick (or blind and deformed).  It could never mean that he may be sick (or blind and deformed). 
Atheism is not only a denial of God; it is a denial of humanity, for to be a man means to be blessed in believing the unbelievable.  My dear atheist friend, you cannot be an atheist because you were conceived out of nothing!  Do you yet not understand?  Man is not only capable of believing what he cannot see but what he can dream, which allows him to eventually realize his dreams.   If he did not dream the impossible dream, then he would forever remain a prisoner in the land of what-you-see-is-what-you-have.  This man is insane, for he sees only what is there and thinks only what is humanly reasonable and observable.  If the world were truly what he could only observe, then the world would be as big as his head: small.
But no atheist ever believed himself.  No atheist will ever tell you that we have discovered everything that exists.  He knows there is still much more to discover; that there is much more that exists.  But for the sake of argument, he pretends to think we have discovered everything and that God does not exist.
Well… the reason why I mention all of this is for the fact that after I spoke, I had a student come up to me and ask me politely never speak about atheism again.  I asked the student why?  She told me that she felt insulted by what I had said.  Now, I must say I was taken aback a little by what she said since I was speaking in a school, in a Catholic school, and in the United States of America – a nation that prides itself on freedom of speech.  I was a little surprised that someone would propose censorship rather than scholarship. 
Now my response surprised the student as much as it surprised me.  I went back to Christianity.  I went back to the paradox of our faith.  I told the young student that what I had said was far less important to me than she was to me.  I told her that I would respect her wish for the time being. 
My response surprised her.  In fact, I think she was stunned, perplexed, at what I had said.  And maybe, just maybe, for the first time in her young atheist life, nothing and no one was as self-evident as her.  Maybe, just maybe, someone no longer fit in her head.


Incoming search terms:

  • beheaded christians prophecy
  • luke 9:7-9 catholic
Fr. Alfonse (1044 Posts)

Readers Comments (7)

  1. You really should stop lying about atheists. I am an atheist who has a beautiful daughter and a thriving marriage of 16 years. I have never used drugs, I have never cheated on my spouse, I have never performed acts of lewd conduct on a child and then ran off to Rome nor have I ever hidden pedophiles in my house so that they can continue sodomizing five-year-olds. Furthermore, I’ve never lied about atheists and then consecrated the Host. Unlike the grotesque Roman Catholic Church, I’ve always obeyed the RULE OF LAW. I put myself through school and earned two masters degrees. Atheist simply means that I LACK A BELIEF IN god, gods, goddesses, godlets, leprechauns, elves, etc. In fact, I am an AGNOSTIC ATHEIST…I am agnostic with regard to knowledge and an atheist with regard to belief. I am a professional photographer and I see beauty ALL the time without the need of a homophobic celestial Sky Daddy who has never healed an amputee. I find absolutely NO reason to believe in a filthy desert god whose “book” is rife with violence, misogyny and a plain “ickiness” that triggers the gag reflex, like watching flies feed. Even if such an entity existed, I would rather be destroyed than spend eternity with an insufferable monster who thinks that substitutionary atonement is a “moral” act. Pure filth. I don’t apologize.

  2. The writer shows his ignorance of atheism and has never met an atheist.
    I don’t question his belief but he should learn more about life in general before attempting to write about atheism.

  3. So you respected her wish as long as it took you to decide to write this? A bit dishonest don’t you think? To brag about how good it was of you to agree to no longer speak about atheists… in a written tirade against atheists.

  4. “For the atheist, nothing is surprising, not even evil; nothing is beautiful, not even love; nothing is exciting, not even life.”

    Sir, I respect your argument and your right to believe whatever you want, but the above statement is not only offensive to atheists such as myself, it is patently false and divisive.

    As an atheist, I acknowledge that evil is pervasive in our society. Atheists recognize the evil in murder, rape, child molestation, animal abuse, fraud, etc., and we do not need a holy book in order to tell us that these actions are immoral. We know these things are inherently wrong because they harm others and rob them of their life and happiness.

    But even with all the evil in the world, atheists find beauty and excitement in discovery, in animals, in nature, in human goodness, in the Cosmos, in art, music, dance, theater, and so many other wonderful things. Although you might believe otherwise, my life is rich and meaningful, because I am the one who ascribes meaning to it.

  5. I think the reason she was offended is because you have a prejudiced view of what atheists are…

  6. It seems that it is you who are the illogical one. Laws of government are made by people. The laws of nature are made by the geometric aspects of how energy moves through 10 or so dimentions. You don’t understand atheist at all. Atheist find beauty in the snowflakes and the cosmos, that beauty is created by the intricacies of that dance that energy does as it wiggles through those dimentions. It is you who are blind to that beauty. This article reads like a Poe.

  7. I don’t feel insulted by what you’ve said about atheist, as much as I feel sure that you’ve never actually asked an atheist what they believe.

    If you had, I’m certain that you wouldn’t have invented that straw man version. Real people are much more complex.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


Hide me
Sign up below to have the hottest Catholic news delivered to your email daily!
Enter your email address:
Show me
Menu Title